« In praise of concón | Main | To Boldly Go »

May 20, 2008

No more stuff!

Slpl I saw this coming, and yet I wish that, for once, we had not followed the trend. There is now a site called Stuff Latin People Like. (The first post is dated April 4.)

You already know what this looks like. It's the same as Stuff White People Like and Stuff Black People Love (not to be confused with Stuff Educated Black People Like), except not even mildly funny (like I thought SWPL was, until I read Gary's spot-on critique here) and not even mildly telling about nonwhites' class anxieties (the way SEBPL is).

And what do we get for the wait? Novelas (#2) Pretend Relatives (#7) and Wal Mart (#15). These barely pass the Homer Simpson test (it's funny coz it's true) and would never get past the first go-around on those email chain letters (I still occasionally get the tried-and-true "you know you're Latino/Puerto Rican/Mexican/Dominican if..." lists, with proper local slang subbed in).

As Daniel Hernandez, among many others, said about SWPL, it was a list that had more to do with class/education/tribe than race/ethnicity.

The site seems to be suffering from the Guanabee syndrome: it must have seemed like a good idea late night and drunk, but the joke cannot be sustained past the first few entries. For satire done right, visit Ask a Mexican.

[image: SLPL banner]

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/2340884/29241474

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference No more stuff!:

Comments

Coulda been great, alas...

I've been very ambivalent about these sites. It's strange, though, since stand-up comedians of all stripes ply their trade in jokes with similar subject matter, and I didn't have much of a problem with it. Maybe because spoken performances have a much more transitory nature? Whatever the case may be, the sites tend to shoehorn a series of cultural, kinship,and identity preferences under the sign of race/ethnicity. And yeah, it gets old.

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

¡A la lucha!

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Heavy rotation

Subway reading

Blog powered by TypePad